The First Thing I Look for in an Offer (Hint: It’s Not the Price)

Table of Contents

Flat lay of laptop and house key with welcome tag — text overlay reads ‘the first thing I look for in an offer (spoiler: it’s not the price)’ — real estate offer tips for sellers in Northern Colorado

As much as I love a strong offer price (who doesn’t?!), there’s one thing I always look for first when reviewing offers with sellers in Northern Colorado — and it’s not the number.

It’s the pre-approval letter. 💕

Before we get too excited, I want to know that a buyer can actually purchase the home. A solid pre-approval gives us confidence that we’re not wasting time — and that the offer is legit.

But that’s just the beginning. Here’s what else I’m looking at when helping sellers evaluate an offer:

Contingencies — Especially if it’s contingent on the buyer selling their home. I dig into whether their house is priced right, show-ready, and likely to sell quickly.

The lender — I do a little happy dance when I see a local lender. It usually means better communication and fewer surprises.

Closing + possession dates — Timing matters. I always try to avoid leaving my sellers in limbo or scrambling to find a place to stay, especially when a slight shift in dates could make all the difference.

Loan type & down payment — It’s not just about the offer amount. I help sellers understand how secure the offer is and how smoothly we can expect the transaction to go.

The buyer’s agent — While this isn’t a deal-breaker, let’s just say… it’s always nice when I see a familiar face and know I’m working with someone professional and responsive.

At the end of the day, a strong offer is about the whole picture — not just the dollar signs.

When I represent sellers, I look beyond the surface to make sure the offer is not only exciting but also solid. Because in this market? A smooth sale > a shaky one with a high price tag.

📍 If you’re thinking about selling your home in Northern Colorado — whether it’s next month or next year — I’d love to walk you through what to expect. I currently have a few spots open for seller consultations and would be happy to put together a smart, strategic plan based on your timeline, goals, and what buyers are actually offering right now. Click here to book your free seller consult.

Share This: